Posted by Lou Pilder on November 10, 2010, at 20:24:51
In reply to Lou's reply-vhalyu » Solstice, posted by Lou Pilder on November 10, 2010, at 19:50:32
> >
> > > Solstice,
> > > You wrote,[...There is just xx yyy to avoid the zzzzzzz that we have a Leader who has some authority that pp qqq else can have. It's the oooo www for a group to survive and thrive...]
> > > I am unsure as to what you are wanting to mean here. If you could post answers to the following, then I could have the opportunity to respond accordingly.
> > > 1A. Do you think that Mr. Hsiung's authority is absolute? If so, could you post here your rationale for such?
> >
> > He owns the site. He created it, and he can shut it down. In the context of this site, he is the absolute authority.
> >
> >
> > > 2A.Why is it according to you a reality?
> >
> > See above. There is absolutely NO possibility for anyone to take away his authority.. other than to not participate.
> >
> >
> > > 1B. Could there be other ways for a group to survive and thrive that could be unbeknownst to you?
> >
> > of course. Considering the vast wealth of possibilities for anything, I know very, very little.
> >
> > > 2B. Would my perspective, being from a Jewish perspective,which is different from yours, be automatically deemed to be (redacted by respondent)
> >
> > I am not Jewish, but my entire adult life I have been immersed in Jewish culture. Working in a Jewish-family owned business, my child being in a school that happened to be founded by a Jew, and having a high ratio of Jewish students, my child ended up falling in love with a Jewish boy. When one of my dearest friends died 3 years ago, the rituals surrounding her funeral and burial were the richest, most meaningful I have ever encountered. I was included in the entire process, and the Synagogue and Rabbi she and her family chose when they first moved here 15 yrs ago - she specifically chose him because he was very inclusive of her non-Jewish friends. The children's Bar Mitzvahs, everything. Your perspective is no more or less valuable than mine - and your Jewishness and my non-Jewishness has nothing to do with the value of our perspectives.
> >
> > Solstice
> >
> Solstice,
> You wrote,[...has nothing to do with the value of our perspectives...]
> Well, without me knowing what it means here by {value}, what is the situation here could be unbeknownst to you as to how the foundation of Judaism is considerd by Mr. Hsiung here.
> I am not permitted by the rules here to post that I believe, through revelation, that the god that I give service and worship to has given me a commandment that I (redacted by respondent)which is the foundation of Judaism. Then there was a post to me that stated that as I see it, that links to posts here can not be posted if what the link leads to has been sanctioned. So I can not IMO post the link to Mr. Hsiung's post to me. Concievably, that could be carried IMO to that I could not tell you where you could get that information as per the link that I have posted here leading to my outstanding requests to Mr. Hsiung that two members here have the concern about that situation and have posted in that thread about their concerns.
> You see, if the foundation of Judiasm could not be posted by me here in that I believe that (redacted by respondent), which is the foundation of Judaism, then if I posted my way here to modify the administration of the site, that would be a different way of administartion than what has been posted here by other members. That difference is not permitted by Mr. Hsiung to me, which could go to or not go to what you are wanting to mean by {value of a perspective}.
> This may be something that you could look into and make your own determination as to if the prohibition to me by Mr. Hsiung to post here what I believe through revelation that is the foundation of Judaism does or does not have to do with the value of my perspective which is from a Jewish perspective.
> Lou
>
> Solstice,
If you are considering doing your own investigation here concerning our topic in discussion here, I am requesting that you look at the following. The links will bring up one post in a thread.
I would like for you to start with this one first
Lou
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20100714/msgs/956252.html
and then
http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20100714/msgs/955927.html
>
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:969088
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20101014/msgs/969712.html