Posted by jane d on March 5, 2004, at 12:23:47
In reply to Re: Discussing politics with dignity » Racer, posted by Dinah on March 5, 2004, at 11:31:42
Please. Some of you weren't here the last time a political topic exploded. It wasn't fun to watch. I don't think there's any way to have a discussion in this medium that doesn't lead to serious misunderstandings. It's hard to read a post supporting or attacking a politicians actions without drawing conclusions about the motivations or reasonining ability of the person posting. Conclusions that could well be wrong. Not everyone who supports this administration is uncaring. Not everyone who opposes it cares about social justice. Because there is so little opportunity for real time back and forth - because it's impossible to clarify what you meant before the other person is enraged by what it sounded like you said - it's probably better not to do this here at all. Whatever is intended it comes across as just speeches. And just what does someones voting position have to do with what they can offer in the way of support and information and insight into mental illness?
Maybe it would work better if we set up a chat time for political discussions instead of having them here. Perhaps one for democrats, one for republicans, and then the free for all for those of us who just love a good fight. Everyone would be there voluntarily. Nothing would be archived to hold against people later and there'd be time to ask people to explain themselves. I guess that is the equivalent of saying "please take this outside" but that really seems to be the right place for this. I might even enjoy a good fight myself somewhere else.
Jane
PS to Faye Roe. Which Faye Roe are you? Before or after?
poster:jane d
thread:320233
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/social/20040305/msgs/320658.html