Re: guidelines and exceptions

Posted by alexandra_k on March 28, 2005, at 3:40:08

In reply to Re: guidelines and exceptions » Dr. Bob, posted by Dinah on March 28, 2005, at 3:08:05

> The problem with asking Lou to rephrase is that Lou is reporting an experience, not a belief. So he can't honestly say that he believes the Rider told him this or that. He has to say that the Rider told him this or that. But I don't see how it's offensive if the Rider told him, Lou, to do something or to believe something. That doesn't in any way follow that the Rider told everyone to do that. Especially if Lou made clear that he wasn't trying to say that the Rider's instructions applied to everyone.
FWIW I agree.

Thread

Another request, Dr. Bob Dinah 3/27/05
Re: guidelines and exceptions Dr. Bob 3/28/05
Re: guidelines and exceptions » Dr. Bob Dinah 3/28/05
Re: guidelines and exceptions alexandra_k 3/28/05
Re: guidelines and exceptions » Dinah mair 3/28/05
Lou's response to Dinah's post-remvex » Dinah Lou Pilder 3/28/05
Re: Lou's response to Dinah's post-remvex » Lou Pilder Dinah 3/28/05
Re: guidelines and exceptions » mair Dinah 3/28/05
Lou's reply to Dinah-btnos » Dinah Lou Pilder 3/28/05
Re: Lou's reply to Dinah-btnos » Lou Pilder alexandra_k 3/28/05
Lou's reply to alexandra_k-rdmnd? » alexandra_k Lou Pilder 3/28/05
Lou's reply to alexandra_k-~pstlnk? » alexandra_k Lou Pilder 3/28/05
Lou's reply to alexandra_k-did~sy? » alexandra_k Lou Pilder 3/28/05
Re: Lou's reply to alexandra_k-did~sy? » Lou Pilder alexandra_k 3/28/05
Re: Lou's reply to alexandra_k-did~sy? » alexandra_k alexandra_k 3/28/05
Lou's reply to alexandra_k-ifthesong is ~accept » alexandra_k Lou Pilder 3/28/05
...
Re: let's keep it administrative here, thanks (nm) Dr. Bob 4/20/05

Post a new follow-up

Notify the administrators

Start a new thread

poster:alexandra_k thread:476237
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20050323/msgs/476617.html

	for
in