Posted by sid on January 27, 2002, at 14:49:47
Dr.Bob,
I understand what you're saying and your choice. This is your web site after all.
I simply think it is misleading to separate the different approaches, and that people battling with terrible mental diseases would benefit more by not separating these approaches (and the discussions on them). I must say I am disappointed by your choice.My experience has been that all approaches have helped me at different times (CBT, acupuncture, meds, yoga), and I find it unfortunate that some people on the different boards sound like you're supposed to choose your camp. It's a very good example of all-or-nothing thinking. I see your web site as a place to get info, share experiences, etc... and frankly, mine does not fit anywhere. The bottom line is that, with the different approaches I took, I am doing well, better than I have before in my adult life, and I am 34. Others should know that and think about more comprehensive, rounded approaches to their disease. I am sure I am not the only one who can benefit from that.
I started meds a few months ago for dysthymia and anxiety, and I needed to read and share with people from psycho babble, but at this point, I find this site less interesting because of the separation of discussions. And because some people seem to prefer obsessing over meds to the point of becoming psychopharmacology experts, while there disease continues to ravage them. Not so interesting. I prefer getting well and not wallowing in my depression - I've done enough of that in the past. So there, I said what I had to say about separatin discussions.
- Sid
poster:sid
thread:2740
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20011216/msgs/2740.html